The Corrupted Face: Fan Theories & Conspiracies About Goku Black
Few villains in Dragon Ball history have sparked as much speculation, debate, and creative theorizing as Goku Black. When a being bearing the face of the series’ beloved hero first appeared in Dragon Ball Super, slaughtering humanity in Future Trunks’s timeline and referring to the Saiyan prince as a mere “Saiyan,” the fandom erupted with questions . Who was this imposter? Was he truly Goku from another timeline? A clone? A relative? The mystery consumed fans for months, generating a cascade of theories that ranged from the emotionally devastating to the cosmically complex. Even after the canon revealed his true identity, the speculative energy around Goku Black never fully dissipated, evolving into new theories about his potential return, his hidden nature, and his place in the multiverse’s dark underbelly.
The Family Conspiracy: Goten and the Fallen Son
The Lost Boy of the Future
The most emotionally charged and widely debated theory during the Goku Black arc’s initial run was the proposition that Goku Black was actually Goten, Goku’s younger son, from an alternate future . This theory resonated deeply with fans because it promised a level of emotional complexity rarely seen in Dragon Ball—the idea that Goku would be forced to fight and possibly kill his own child.
The evidence, at first glance, seemed compelling. Goten and Goku share an almost identical appearance, especially in their youth . As adults, the resemblance would only become more pronounced, making the visual confusion plausible within the narrative. The theory’s proponents argued that Goten, neglected by a father constantly absent for training and cosmic battles, could have been corrupted by resentment, eventually turning against Trunks and the world he was meant to protect .
The emotional stakes were staggering. Goku, who had already experienced the loss of his brother Raditz and the temporary sacrifice of his son Gohan, would face a tragedy of an entirely different order: a son who had become a monster wearing his own face, a living embodiment of his failures as a parent. The theory tapped into the series’ under-explored theme of familial consequence, suggesting that Goku’s relentless pursuit of strength had finally borne poisoned fruit .
The Timeline Problem
Despite its emotional appeal, the Goten theory faced formidable obstacles. The most significant was the nature of Future Trunks’s timeline itself. In that ravaged world, Goku had died years earlier from the heart virus, and without his father’s presence, Goten was never born . The Goten of Trunks’s world simply did not exist.
However, theory defenders proposed a loophole: alternate timelines and parallel dimensions. If Goku Black could travel between timelines, perhaps he was a Goten from another alternate future, one where he had survived and grown into a bitter, vengeful adult . The theory’s persistence, even after the canon revelation, speaks to its narrative power. It represented a road not taken—a darker, more psychologically complex direction for the series that many fans still wish could be explored .
The Goten Black Legacy
The Goten theory never died; it evolved. In the years since the Goku Black arc concluded, fans have continued to imagine “what if” scenarios where Goten becomes corrupted . The idea has been further fueled by discussions of “Gohan Black Beast,” a theoretical dark counterpart to Gohan’s powerful Beast form . If Gohan could have a dark mirror, why not Goten? The family conspiracy endures because it asks a question the canon never answered: what happens to the sons of heroes when their fathers are too busy saving the world to notice they’re losing their children?
The Ancestral Conspiracy: Bardock, Turles, and the Saiyan Bloodline
The Father’s Shadow
Before the Goten theory took hold, another familial speculation dominated fan discussions: Goku Black might be Bardock, Goku’s father . This theory drew inspiration from Dragon Ball Xenoverse, where a brainwashed Bardock appears as “Bardock Berserker,” wearing a Time Breaker mask and serving the villain Mira. The visual similarities—the face, the fighting style, the Saiyan aggression—suggested a connection.
Proponents argued that Bardock, somehow transported to the future or resurrected through temporal manipulation, could have been corrupted into becoming Goku Black. His hatred for Freeza and the forces that destroyed Planet Vegeta might have been twisted into a genocidal mission against all mortals . The theory had a certain poetic symmetry: the father becoming the villain his son would have to defeat.
However, the theory collapsed under scrutiny. Bardock bears a distinctive facial scar, a permanent marker of his battle history. Goku Black has no such scar . While the series has occasionally ignored minor continuity details, such a prominent physical difference was difficult to explain away.
The Forgotten Brother
Another ancestral candidate emerged: Turles, the villain of the film Dragon Ball Z: The Tree of Might . Turles, a low-class Saiyan who bore a striking resemblance to Goku, was often described as a “evil Goku” years before Goku Black existed. The theory proposed that Turles, somehow surviving his film’s conclusion or being resurrected through temporal mechanics, could have become Goku Black.
Turles’s design—particularly his darker skin tone—posed a problem, but theorists noted that Goku’s own coloration had varied across adaptations . The deeper issue was narrative: Turles was a one-dimensional villain, a Saiyan who simply wanted to conquer. Transforming him into the philosophically driven, god-complex-afflicted Goku Black would require extensive character development the series never provided.
The Shadow Dragon
A more obscure theory linked Goku Black to Goku Shadow, a character from Dragon Ball Heroes, the promotional manga illustrated by Toyotaro before he became the official artist for Dragon Ball Super . Goku Shadow was a dark, childlike version of Goku who appeared in the Heroes continuity. The connection was tantalizing: Toyotaro’s involvement suggested he might have recycled or evolved the concept for Super.
The theory’s weakness lay in tonal and visual discrepancies. Goku Shadow was a child, and his darkness was presented more as a supernatural phenomenon than a philosophical stance. Goku Black was an adult, and his evil was cold, calculated, and ideological. The connection, while interesting, remained speculative .
The Android Conspiracy: The Red Ribbon’s Last Experiment
A Machine Built for Revenge
A more technologically inclined theory proposed that Goku Black was an android created by the remnants of the Red Ribbon Army . This theory drew on the established lore of Dr. Gero and his creations, including the Androids 17 and 18, and the bio-android Cell. If the Red Ribbon could create such powerful beings, why not one designed specifically to be the ultimate Goku-killer?
The theory suggested that in Future Trunks’s timeline, the Red Ribbon’s remnants—or a successor organization—activated a sleeper android programmed with Goku’s battle data and appearance . This would explain Black’s familiarity with Goku’s techniques and his obsessive focus on eradicating Saiyans and mortals.
The Ki Problem
However, the android theory encountered a fundamental obstacle: ki detection. In Dragon Ball, androids like 17 and 18 produce no ki, making them invisible to sensing techniques. Goku Black, by contrast, not only has ki but uses it prolifically—firing energy blasts, executing Kamehamehas, and powering up in classic Saiyan fashion. He also can be sensed by other characters, a property androids lack .
The theory’s defenders proposed a hybrid model: perhaps Black was a “bio-android” like Cell, combining organic Saiyan components with mechanical enhancements. This would allow him to possess ki while still being an artificial creation. But the explanation felt forced, and the theory gradually lost traction as the arc progressed and other clues emerged .
The Clone Conspiracy: Genetic Copies and Cellular Memory
The Cell Template
Building on the android theory, a related speculation proposed that Goku Black was a clone, created using Goku’s DNA . The precedent was clear: Cell was created from the genetic material of Goku, Vegeta, Piccolo, Frieza, and others. If Dr. Gero could accomplish that decades earlier, a later organization could certainly create a pure Goku clone.
This theory elegantly explained Black’s appearance, his techniques, and his Saiyan characteristics. It also accounted for his ability to grow stronger through battle, a trait Saiyans exhibit and that clones might inherit . The clone would be a blank slate, which could then be programmed with whatever personality and mission its creators desired.
The Zamasu Connection
The clone theory gained additional complexity when Zamasu entered the narrative. Some fans proposed that the clone body could have been inhabited or possessed by Zamasu’s consciousness, explaining the godly powers and philosophical motivations that a pure Saiyan clone wouldn’t naturally possess . This hybrid theory—clone body plus divine soul—prefigured the canon revelation while adding an extra layer of manufactured tragedy.
The Resurrection Conspiracy: Dark Instinct and the Return
The Scattered Remnants
Even after Goku Black’s apparent erasure at the end of the Future Trunks Saga, his story refuses to end in the minds of fans. A persistent and elaborately developed theory proposes that Goku Black will return, and when he does, he will bring a terrifying new ability: “Dark Instinct” .
The theory’s mechanics are intricate. After Zamasu’s fusion with the timeline itself and his subsequent erasure by Zeno, his consciousness was not completely destroyed. Fragments of his being—remnants of a divine entity—drifted across the multiverse, carried by currents of corrupted time energy . Over years or decades, these fragments slowly coalesced, absorbing power from broken dimensions and damaged timelines.
The catalyst for full resurrection would be a forbidden Kai ritual, one that channels dimensional energy into a complete physical form. This ritual would resurrect not Zamasu as he was, but Goku Black—the fused identity of Zamasu’s consciousness and Goku’s body, now hardened by suffering and refined by time .
The Corrupted Divine
This resurrected Goku Black would not be the reckless god-in-training who originally appeared. He would be patient, calculating, and driven by a new purpose. Having witnessed Goku’s mastery of Ultra Instinct, the divine technique of the Angels, he would seek to create its antithesis: Dark Instinct .
Where Ultra Instinct is rooted in calm, tranquility, and letting go, allowing the body to react without thought, Dark Instinct would invert every principle. It would be brutal, violent, and calculating. The user would not move with the flow of combat but dictate and control it. Goku Black would deliberately allow himself to be hit, not to grow stronger (as in Vegeta’s Ultra Ego), but to absorb information from each attack, storing data to calculate the most efficient path to victory .
The visual manifestation would be equally inverted: a black mist streaked with violet arcs, an aura of corruption surrounding a being who has embraced the darkest aspects of divinity .
The Philosophical War
If Dark Instinct were realized, Dragon Ball Super would enter a new thematic dimension. The conflict would become a philosophical war about the nature of divinity itself. Can godly techniques be corrupted? Is divine power inherently neutral, or does it have a moral dimension? If Goku Black can corrupt one Angel technique, could he corrupt others, becoming an entity that even the gods fear? .
This theory transforms Goku Black from a mere villain into a cosmic threat, one whose ambition extends beyond destroying mortals to challenging the entire divine hierarchy. His goal would be not just revenge but apotheosis—becoming a god beyond gods, a being of pure corrupted divinity .
The Multiverse Conspiracy: The Infinite Goku Blacks
The Zamasu Multiplicity
The canon established that multiple Zamasus exist across different timelines—the Zamasu of the main timeline (killed by Beerus), the Zamasu of Future Trunks’s timeline (who became Goku Black), and presumably others . This multiplicity opens the door to a chilling possibility: there could be infinite Goku Blacks.
If any Zamasu in any timeline gains access to the Super Dragon Balls and the opportunity to steal Goku’s body, another Goku Black could emerge. The multiverse could contain countless such horrors, each with its own variation of the stolen Saiyan body and corrupted divine purpose .
The Gohan Black Variant
The multiverse theory has recently evolved into speculation about “Gohan Black Beast,” a dark counterpart to Gohan’s powerful Beast form . If Zamasu could steal Goku’s body, what prevents another entity—perhaps a different Zamasu, or an entirely different being—from stealing Gohan’s? The idea has captured fans’ imagination because Gohan’s power, particularly in his Beast state, rivals or even exceeds Goku’s .
A hypothetical Gohan Black would combine the intellectual cunning of Gohan with the divine corruption of Zamasu, producing a villain far more strategic and potentially more dangerous than the original Goku Black. The Beast form’s raw power, filtered through Zamasu’s fanatical ideology, would be a nightmare for the multiverse .
This theory remains purely speculative, but its persistence demonstrates the enduring fascination with the “Black” concept. The idea of beloved heroes being corrupted into villains, their faces twisted into masks of hatred, taps into a deep narrative vein that fans cannot stop exploring .
The Ultimate Theory: Goku Black as Goku’s Worst Self
The Loss of Identity
Beyond all the speculative identities—Goten, Bardock, Future Goku, android, clone—lies a deeper, more philosophical interpretation. Goku Black represents Goku’s worst possible self, stripped of everything that makes him a hero .
Zamasu, in stealing Goku’s body, also stole his potential, his power, and his face. But he could not steal his heart. The tragedy of Goku Black is that he possesses all of Goku’s strength and none of his compassion, all of his Saiyan drive and none of his love for Earth and its people. He is Goku reduced to pure combat potential, a weapon without a conscience .
This interpretation reframes the entire Goku Black arc as a cautionary tale about identity and legacy. Goku’s journey has been about growth, connection, and the discovery that strength serves friendship. Goku Black represents the alternative path—strength serving only itself, power without purpose, divinity without humanity .
The Mirror Held Up
When Goku faces Goku Black, he is not just fighting a villain. He is confronting the possibility that his own body, his own power, could be turned to evil ends. The fight becomes existential: if Goku’s body can become the instrument of genocide, what does that say about Goku himself? Is he merely the current occupant of a vessel that could be filled by anyone? .
The canon’s answer—that Goku’s body was stolen, not corrupted from within—provides comfort but does not fully dispel the unease. Goku Black remains a mirror, a dark reflection that asks uncomfortable questions about the nature of heroism and the fragility of identity. In a universe where bodies can be swapped, memories erased, and souls transplanted, what makes a hero a hero? .
See also : Fan Theories in Dragon Ball Series, What is Fan Theory and Conspiracy Theory in Games and Anime
The Enduring Mystery
Years after his arc concluded, Goku Black continues to generate theories because he represents something fundamental to Dragon Ball‘s appeal: the idea that nothing is fixed, that heroes can fall, that faces can lie. The theories about his identity—Goten, Bardock, Future Goku, clone—are not just attempts to solve a mystery. They are explorations of possibility, ways of asking “what if?” that keep the series alive in fans’ imaginations.
The ultimate theory about Goku Black may be that he is not a single identity but a placeholder for all the dark possibilities the series cannot explore in its main narrative. He is the shadow self of the Saiyan race, the embodiment of everything Goku could have been if he had made different choices, if he had been born in a different time, if he had never hit his head as a child.
In that sense, Goku Black is not Zamasu. He is not Goten. He is not Bardock. He is the face in the mirror that every hero fears, the possibility that the line between savior and destroyer is thinner than anyone wants to admit. And that is why, no matter how many times his true identity is revealed, the theories will never stop.
Pingback: Conspiracies and Fan Theory in Dragon Ball Series – Akusaa.com discuss Anime, Gaming, and misc things